Translate

30 Temmuz 2017 Pazar

Which Criteria Is The Best? AIC or BIC?

In all ARMA models we must decided th number of the AR and MA terms. For this reason some criterias such as, AIC, BSC, FPE, HQ developed by the econometricians. AIC and BSC cirterias are widely used by the researchers. But some resreachers prefer the BSC criteria than AIC. The question is why do reseachers prefer BSC to AIC criteria. The answer of this question is originated form the AIC and BSC formula. Let us investigate the AIC and BSC formula respectively.



Our main purpose is that, select the order p (numer of p)which is minimize the AIC or BIC criterias. The first part of the right side is same in both criteria, however the second part is differenced each other.  The second part in both criterias are relative with the penalty for order p. AIC criteria consider only the number of p, but BIC consider both the number of p and  observations. BIC criteria also consider number of observation and  lead to more penalty for the function. So this reason, BIC is smaller than AIC and it is more reliable[1].



[1] For the detatiled informations: Jianqing Fan and Qiwei Yao-Nonlinear Time Series. Parametric and Non-parametric Methods p-99-104.

Hiç yorum yok :

Yorum Gönder